?

Log in

No account? Create an account
asleep at mal 9/09
alumiere
The Privledges and Harassment that are part of "Being Pretty" 
8/25/10 5:32
asleep at mal 9/09
karnythia started a pretty amazing discussion today (please read her post and some of the comments for more context - but if you comment there, please don't be that guy/girl), and given that I can't sleep at the moment, I thought I'd write...

First, I don't really believe I'm pretty in any conventional sense (and this is not a plea for "yes, you are"). But I do seem to fall within a subset of society's norm for women. I present as white, cis, hetero, fit, and female; in reality I'm a bit of a mutt, bi, polyamorous, disabled (albeit in decent shape) and female. But I dress on the feminine end of the spectrum, so even with the purple mohawk and a cane I must be "asking for it".

But through most of my college and grad years I dressed in baggy shorts/pants and oversized t-shirts with the same mohawk (in an ever changing array of colors). It didn't stop the harassment on the street or unwanted advances, nor did it do anything to weed out the asshats or deter the men capable of date rape. I'm not that attractive that I understand how I was lucky enough to get attention when I looked like a skater boi, especially since even now I'm a C-cup at best. I outgrew the skate-punk style when I figured out it didn't make a difference, and skirts are more comfortable to wear.

These days I don't get as much in the way of street harassment, mainly because I rarely leave the house, especially alone (go go Transient Global Amnesia). I still get catcalls, honks, stares, rude comments and people trying to touch me without permission when I am out (usually with my male partner), even if it's just at the grocery store or the laundromat and I'm wearing a long skirt and a t-shirt or a baggy comfy dress covered by my cassock/coat. It's not OK.

On the other hand, I also get things like you can't possibly be disabled or sick; you look so young and healthy. Or people who ask why I use a cane, why I have an escort, what could I possibly be doing taking all those medications; I'm obviously too pretty to have health problems.

And then there's work - up until I lost my job last year, I spent over a decade working in male dominated fields. Retail at Home Depot and Electronics Boutique (now Gamestop) where women are expected to be hot and stupid, and then as a Cisco Tech for ISPs where women aren't expected to be working at all.

At EB I was one of two female managers in our region, and our DM and RM both encouraged me to hire other attractive girls to work for the store - even with some of the highest numbers in terms of profit they thought more hot girls would bring in more business. After all, if the geeks responded to me by spending that much money in the store, imagine how much more they'd buy if the whole staff was female (it couldn't be because I'm good at my job, it had to be my looks and the fact that I wore dresses and skirts to work in). At the same time, they displayed sexist behavior, expecting me to be incapable of figuring out what was wrong when our computer system crashed or a shipment got fucked up. Oh, and no, you can't have an in-store security system; it's not cost effective even though your theft/loss numbers are too high because you are constantly understaffed and everyone is working by themselves for hours at a time. It was maddening to the point that I stepped down as manager before I had a new job and could quit.

At least I got mostly lucky in that my co-workers at the ISPs knew me prior to my being hired, and expected me to know my shit and be good at what I was doing. But our customers often fought back against explanations or assistance from a woman, especially if they met me or saw my picture on our webpage. After all, how can a woman, let alone an attractive one in a skirt, know how to fix their internet service? I must be either sleeping with the boss or the token female, don't you know... So even in a job where people knew I was good, I had to work harder to earn the same level of respect.

And men, holding the door open (and getting in the way of my cane), offering to carry my single bag, acting like I can't handle a few groceries without assistance is infuriating. If I know you and need help I will ask; if I don't, grabbing my bags to carry them for me isn't help, it's threatening. I'm perfectly capable of picking up 40-50 pounds of crap even with the cane provided it's properly loaded; there's a reason I carry the cloth grocery bags and pack them myself most of the time. I may seem small to you, but if I'm feeling good enough to leave the house by myself (rare) I'm quite sure I'm competent to get myself and my packages home safely.

It's impossible to win. I have privilege because of my perceived race/sexuality, my visible femininty. But I get treated as less than for the same traits. Why not pay attention to who I am, what I'm actually capable of (or not) rather than how I appear? Oh, right, we live in a world where women, especially "pretty" ones, are not equal or capable, we skate by on our looks, and at the same time if we're thin and seem young we can't be disabled.

And people wonder why I get so angry, why I treat my friends so well, what makes the family I choose, the "freak" scene such an important part of who I am. Simple - there I'm female, but I'm accepted for who I am, and not treated as a fragile flower or an idiot just because of it. Also, when I'm out at a "freak" event I can stomp on an asshat or quickly have him removed from the club - we take care of our own.

ETA: Being part of the freak community still has problems though - a lot of guys think I'm easy, a sex worker, looking for attention because of the way I look. Or they find my appearance/behavior threatening. Fortunately I decided years ago that dating someone who wasn't part of the club scene didn't work, so I don't care about the later, and I ignore the former or brush them off quickly. At least the intimidation factor makes it a bit less problematic from my POV - I have a level of confidence that I didn't used to have, and I'm not afraid to stomp feet with my spiked heels or throw elbows in the club when someone gives me shit (only after I ask politely once or twice). In some ways being a punk gives me a way to navigate the ups and downs of sexist behaviors that looking more normal did not.
Comments 
8/25/10 16:43 (UTC)
I headed over to karnythia's post and found some of the comments insane (as in: "holy crap, shit like that happens?"). I'm not sure if it's because of where I was raised or because I look like a boring teenager without makeup on but I can't recall ever being harrassed to that extent, either in the workplace or on the streets (Then again I can be pretty oblivious at times). The worst I recall getting around here is 'hey, nice dreads' so reading about your experiences and those of the girls on the other post is an eye-opener in a way. Misogyny is something I rarely consider and i'm starting to think that it's something that I should be more aware of (though I am aware of it in a statistic and monetary sense).

I'm wondering how much of an impact location vs. type-of-pretty (body-type, hairstyle, etc) has on the intensity of harrassment/prejudice.
8/26/10 6:55 (UTC)
Unfortunately, yes, that shit happens, all the time. I think it's more prevalent in big cities, while if I remember correctly you grew up in a more rural area.

Part of it may be where you live/work as well, and the fact that you tend to spend more time in less traditional communities. I don't get much shit in the freak community, but I can remember the stares and comments when I lived in NYC and Baltimore or used to metro into DC regularly, and LA is pretty much the same.

On the other hand, I'm a city girl through and through, and while I don't like it, the harassment goes with the territory. Men in particular need an attitude adjustment, but women can be misogynistic too.

There are some great sites that spend a lot of time talking about this; two of my favorites atm are http://myfaultimfemale.wordpress.com/ and http://hollabackdc.wordpress.com/ (there are groups worldwide participating in Holla Back, noting locations and taking pictures/video when possible of harassers).
8/26/10 5:44 (UTC)
I saw your comment in Karnythia's journal; I'm interested in an aspect that's rather off-topic from her original post, so if it's alright I'd like to discuss here. May I ask about this part?

And men, holding the door open (and getting in the way of my cane), offering to carry my single bag, acting like I can't handle a few groceries without assistance is infuriating. If I know you and need help I will ask; if I don't, grabbing my bags to carry them for me isn't help, it's threatening.

I normally hold doors open for people if I arrive that 3-5 steps ahead of them that makes it natural to do so. I don't check for gender or apparent ability; it's just a courtesy I can offer a fellow human being, preferable to smacking them in the face with the door. I have been known to offer strangers assistance with packages, or more extensive help with doors, or my seat on the train, when I was aware that someone was using a cane, in a wheelchair, eight months pregnant, etc. I try to phrase such offers as "would you like..." or "may I..." rather than as "do you need..." And I try to make it clear that they're *offers*, not assumptions of incompetence; if the answer is no, I'll smile and get out of the way.

Would you consider those kinds of offers polite? Or is any kind of offer too fraught with baggage from people being patronizing? Would your answer be different if I were male?

Feel free to tell me to take a hike if I'm prying.
8/26/10 6:25 (UTC)
You're not being patronizing at all; it's a valid question, and from your description it sounds like you handle things pretty well. Not all people are asshats, but I struggle with balancing out behavior toward the well meaning but sometimes clueless with those who think I'm incapable or an easy mark. I probably also have a bit of a chip on my shoulder as I re-learn how to navigate life with limitations I didn't have a few years ago, so some of this may be me being prickly about needing a cane at all.

And in truth how I answer/act depends on the situation. For better or worse, much of our world is not well-suited to those of us who are differently abled or use wheelchairs, canes, walkers, etc. Many doors are narrow, or open in a way that having them held for us make it difficult or impossible to navigate through them. But if that's the case an you're holding the door out of politeness to a I'll usually say thanks and motion you ahead so I can get through.

And in some cases it would make a difference if you're male, at least for me. If you holding the door open puts me at risk of groping or uncomfortable contact I'm much more likely to answer no thanks, it's easier for me to open it myself to a man. But that may be a result of previous experiences. The cane makes me appear (and sometimes feel) more vulnerable, so the increased "chivalry" becomes problematic.

On the other hand, my cane is also heavy, with either a carbon fiber or titanium shaft, and wielded as a club can be quite effective as a weapon if necessary (ie: groping me when I have it in my hand may earn you some serious bruises on your calves or if you're really bad a smack in the balls). Given that other women with similar disabilities have made the same point in their own blogs though, I think it's pretty common - we appreciate help when it's offered politely, even though we may sometimes turn it down.

I hope I'm not being too harsh here; over the years I've been trampled on, had my cane knocked out from under me, been grabbed trying to get past people in doorways, store aisles, and so on. But for most of the last decade I've only used the cane when I had to do a major amount of walking; these days a trip to the 7-11 on the corner requires it, which means an increased frequency of incidents, and more consciousness on my part of the situations in which problems occur.
8/26/10 8:00 (UTC)
Protecting yourself is NOT "being harsh."

I am intrigued by all the tiny things that distinguish kindness from patronization. Someone on the other thread made some fairly broad remarks about opening doors and all "chivalry" being mechanisms to "put women in their place." Which I don't totally buy. They can be, but there are timing and body language cues that differentiate "I would like to do this nice thing for you" from "It is my job to look out for you because you cannot possibly be competent to manage the simplest thing yourself." And body language can be misread. I have had men stop dead and *refuse* to walk through a door I was holding for them. Meanwhile, my SO and I have fun with those "airlock" style double doors so many public places have-- he opens the first door for me, I walk through and open the second door for him, and we make an entrance in fine egalitarian style.

So, it sounds like my best bet in making offers of assistance is: start from the assumption that the person *probably* has everything under control, while *possibly* I could make things a little more pleasant. I hear you about allowing enough space, both literal space in narrow doorways and figurative space in not being intrusive.